It's Spooky Season, and I still can't stop thinking about Obsession, the Curry Barker-directed film released in May of this year. The film feels timely given the recent news cycles focused on male/female power dynamics with things like the Epstein Files and the Cornell Seven. These horrific events seem to be what Obsession is trying to draw attention to, as it's all too accepted by the culture. It seems Barker was using the film to say that these situations are the natural fallout when society normalizes the "nice guy" who thinks he deserves whatever he wants from a woman because he's overly nice to the object of his infatuation: typically a female with no interest in him.
While watching Obsession, I kept coming back to the idea of the pursuit of the ideal; specifically the difference between the "desire for a person" and the reality of a relationship. This is a central theme of The Great Gatsby as well, albeit without a horror element.
The Great Gatsby follows Nick Carraway, who tells the novel from his perspective as he moves back east and reconnects with his cousin, Daisy Buchanan. Nick is neighbors with the enigmatic and wealthy Jay Gatsby. Nick becomes friends with Gatsby, who has a lingering love for Daisy. She's married, but that makes Gatsby's infatuation all the more interesting. Daisy's husband, Tom, also has a secret love affair, really emphasizing just how disorderly their relationship is. Gatsby uses Nick's relationship with Daisy to build a romantic relationship with her, creating a messy group dynamic.
The obvious question is: "How does a rich man who wants to rekindle his old flame equate to a group of friends where one guy is pining after this unrequited love interest, so he wishes on a magic object to make her fall in love with him?"
The Great Gatsby romanticizes a relationship from a more masculine perspective, while Obsession takes that idea to its logical extreme, where the woman's agency is stripped away. It feels like The Great Gatsby, a renowned American classic, romanticizes pining after a woman who has, by all accounts, moved on with her life after a brief fling. Obsession has this idea, but takes it a step further, saying, "What if we completely removed ALL of the woman's autonomy by forcing her into a situation where she becomes, quite literally, obsessed with the man infatuated with her?"
Examining it further, Obsession follows the story of Barron (Bear), played by Michael Johnson, as he navigates the transition from high school into adulthood and college with his three best friends. Bear has an idealized crush on one of the girls in the group, Nikki, played by Inde Navarrette. This infatuation turns into something much more obsessive when Bear cracks what he thought was a silly little children's toy called a One Wish Willow and wishes that "Nikki Freeman would love me more than anyone in the fucking world." This wish backfires when Nikki's love becomes her entire personality, and she struggles to function without Bear around.
On the first watch of Obsession, you get the immediate "monkey's paw" feeling, the idea that you need to be careful and exact with your wishes because they can come true and come back to bite you. But if you rewatch it through the lens of a man seeking his ideal, the movie really starts to hit on the power dynamics between men and women and how the "good guy" thinks he should always win, even if winning means forcing the relationship to fit his own ideas of what it should look like.
The first time Gatsby is seen in the novel, he's staring out from a dock at a green light. This is a visual cue for him staring at his ideal and picturing the perfect life he has envisioned. The opening of Obsession is a scene with Bear pouring his heart out to a girl. The viewer initially thinks this is him confessing to Nikki, but it becomes evident that he is practicing his ideal to a random waiter at a restaurant. Bear and Gatsby are both doing the same thing: idealizing their end goal and imagining themselves with the woman they have been romanticizing.
When we examine the dynamic between Bear and his best friend Ian (Cooper Tomlinson), we get to see how the two men treat Nikki in a way that removes her independence for personal gain. Specifically, Bear is trying to come up with an idea to get himself alone with Nikki to make her fall in love with him. Ian is encouraging this behavior (with the exception of doing it at trivia night). The duo is plotting a way to make what they want happen, without even once considering Nikki's desires, immediately removing her autonomy.
Interestingly, The Great Gatsby has the introduction of Daisy and her husband Tom having lunch with Nick. Tom goes on a racist tirade utilizing a pseudo-intellectual argument. When Daisy tries to add some ideas to the conversation, Tom dismisses her thoughts, showing that Daisy isn't allowed to have complex thoughts. Tom, the man who is supposed to love Daisy more than anyone, starts their on-screen dynamic by showing that she isn't allowed to have her own opinion, a complete removal of her autonomy.
There is a scene in Obsession that really encapsulates the exact theme of both stories and the men's immature understanding of love. After playing trivia, Bear takes Nikki home, and she explains that she is quitting the job at the music store where they work together. She has already put in her two weeks. When he asks about it, she says she needs a change of scenery and wants to feel love.
Bear says, "Oh, so you're writing a romance."
Nikki says, "It's not a romance! It's a love story."
Bear responds, "Isn't that the same thing?"
That's the quintessential scene highlighting the problem with Bear's understanding of a relationship. It's romanticized. It's the same as Gatsby's view of his relationship with Daisy. Both men think of their relationships as perfect, and as everything they believe they should be. They are craving an idealized version of what they THINK relationships look like. They have this perfect version in their heads where their chosen person should be completely devoted to them.
Both relationships move fast within the context of their respective stories, too. Bear makes his wish, and there is a scene where he and Nikki are at work together and suddenly seem to be deeply in love. She's showing him a meme online that describes wanting to wear the other person's skin. It's essentially an "overnight" transformation of their relationship. Nikki basically fully moves in with Bear before her two weeks at the store are even up.
Similarly, Nick invites Gatsby and Daisy over for tea. They’re a bit awkward with each other at first, but Nick leaves the room and comes back to find them completely entranced with one another. Their relationship undergoes a drastic shift very quickly from that point on. You could even argue that this "set-up" for a planned "meet-cute" removes Daisy's autonomy. She doesn't know that her long-lost ex-boyfriend is going to be at this meeting. She doesn't know he's been pining this whole time. We just see that their relationship is mysteriously rekindled.
Which also feels pretty similar to how the One Wish Willow mysteriously sparks a "romantic" relationship between Bear and Nikki.
Both men jump into their relationships with both feet. They are completely invested in a relationship that they have built up in their own heads. Neither gave it time to actually develop and turn into a truly committed relationship.
I get to this place because, in general American culture, men aren't seen as romantics. In pop culture, we see men as big, gruff, and tough dudes. They are the heroes. They ride in on their horses, shoot the bad guy, win the girl, and ride off into the sunset. They are the superheroes who come to the aid of the damsel in distress, who then falls immediately in love with them. It's such a common narrative that these incredibly broad analogies probably brought many different stories to mind.
If we use this cultural framework to analyze these stories, we see Jay Gatsby as a traditionally masculine character who has a tragic love story. He spends his life pining after a girl who left him while he was at war. Popular media often takes a liking to men who have pined after a girl for an extended period of time. Jim from The Office (U.S.) is idealized despite continually pursuing Pam even though she's engaged. Professor Snape in the Harry Potter series is believed to be a great character for his love of Harry's mom since their childhood. Both characters do things that would be inherently immoral had they occurred outside of popular media. If this sort of behavior occurs in real life, the general public doesn't take too kindly to it. They would say it's "weird" and "not cool," encouraging the man to move on. But when we see Gatsby do this same thing, it's encouraged that he "wins" the girl.
You can make the argument that Daisy's husband, much like Pam's fiancé, is a bad person. However, that doesn't make it right to unilaterally decide that you're going to force a romantic relationship. This approval, whether inadvertently or not, has led to the natural progression of men thinking they just "deserve" to be the target of their desire's love for being nice. Really it's not that simple.
Jumping back to Obsession, there are two major scenes that really stand out as examples of how oppressive Bear's one-sided decision-making about their relationship is.
The first is a scene where Bear and Nikki are having sex, and Bear is completely lost in the moment. In his mind, this is absolutely everything he ever wanted. But if you look at Nikki's face, she's absently staring off to the side, and you see a single tear roll down her cheek. In the context of the moment, we are watching what is framed as a romantic moment meant to express their love in Bear's mind, but for Nikki it is rape because she has no autonomy. It's a situation where Bear is making decisions about Nikki's body to satisfy his own desires because his wish stole her ability to make any decisions. She lost her ability to consent to anything, much less something so intimate.
This jumps back to his fundamental misunderstanding of a "love story" versus a "romance." Bear sees a romance as a perfect story where he gets what he wants. But a love story is much, much more. Love is about both parties being willing. Love is about both parties being invested emotionally, intellectually, and physically. It's willing and intentional. It's fighting through adversity toward a more positive future for both parties.
The second scene that shows just how distorted and, frankly, disgusting Bear's understanding of their relationship is occurs later in the film. By this point, Bear has already recognized that Nikki's behavior is strange. He gets up in the middle of the night to go see Sarah, who has actually shown interest in Bear despite his complete desire being singularly focused on Nikki. When he gets up to leave, he's being so quiet that we hear Nikki call out. Bear freezes, and Nikki says, "She's not here right now. It isn't me. It hasn't been me." She asks him to kill her so that she doesn't have to live this possessed life. Nikki wants to be able to make decisions herself, do things for herself, BE herself. Bear says, "Is it really so bad being with me?" Then he leaves.
So, he's not a victim of this wish going crazy; he's a part of it. It's not clear if Nikki is aware that the entire situation is due to Bear’s wish. He had an opportunity to really free her. Instead, he walks away. He, once again, ignores her desires for his own. Ironically at that, since he's going to meet a different girl.
Bear romanticizes the relationship because it's what HE wants. Gatsby organizes tea to meet up with Daisy because it's what HE wants. Taking it a level further, Snape bullies Harry because he looks like Harry's dad, who bullied Snape as a child, and it's his way to punish the man who "stole his girl." Jim kisses Pam despite her engagement because it's what HE wants. And society romanticizes these relationships in favor of the male. The natural progression is Bear completely removing the agency of the woman and forcing her to be in a relationship with him.
The craziest part is that Gatsby never has the opportunity to live out his ideal life because of the car wreck with Daisy that leads to his death. Bear doesn't get to fully live out his obsessed life either because he ends up overdosing to end the reign of terror caused by possessed Nikki.
Ultimately, Obsession is a natural progression from years of society telling us how a relationship works. Years of media encouragement for a specific dynamic have led to the opposite being absolutely terrifying. If this does nothing else, I hope that this article raises awareness of how traditional roles can be potentially harmful. Each relationship is unique; each relationship should be handled with what works for them.